All or None
Don’t judge if
they’re tall
Don’t judge if
they’re short
Don’t judge if
they’re religious
Don’t judge if
they’re not
Don’t judge if
they’re gay
Don’t judge if
they’re straight
Don’t judge if
they’re quiet
Don’t judge if
they’re loud
Don’t judge if
they’re a girl
Don’t judge if
they’re a boy
Don’t judge if
they’re neither
Don’t judge if
they’re both
Don’t judge if
they’re black
Don’t judge if
they’re white
Don’t judge if
they’re blind
Don’t judge if
they’re deaf
Don’t judge if
they’re all or none of those things
We’re all still people.
Criticism: I'll take any type of criticism or ideas
I'm kind of iffy about the format...suggestions??
ReplyDeleteI think the depth of the message you're trying to send in repetition in the poem is very nice.
ReplyDeleteFor the format, it would be kind of cool if it looked like this:
Don’t judge if Don’t judge if
they’re tall they’re short
Then, the poem will take up less space up and down on the page. Plus, it sets up a direct comparison between each of the statements that match each other.
Question: For the lines: "Don’t judge if they’re all or none of those things," I know you don't literally mean "all or none". What I understood from your poem is: whatever characteristics someone has, it makes no difference whether or not they deserve to be judged because different characteristics don't hold different weights. It's not true that some characteristics deserve to be judged while others don't, it's just that all of them don't deserve to be judged.
However, when I read the "all or none" part, my logical mind was confused for a sec, because I realized that someone couldn't have "all" of those characteristics because some of them are completely opposite (someone can't literally be "tall" and "short" at the same time). I feel like that line and the last line of the poem could be refined a bit to more clearly express the depth of what you're trying to say.
Yea, I agree because when I wrote "All or None" I did realize that some of the things I said were complete opposites and it was impossible to be both of these things at the same time, but I just think it's more effective than saying "Don't judge if they're some or none of these things." Maybe I could say "Don't judge if they're any or none of these things?" But I don't like that as much, plus I wanted to be all inclusive. Maybe the last sentence isn't logical, but I think it gets the point across.
DeleteAlso thank you for the feedback and compliment.
Delete